Are Vitamin D and Fish Oil Supplements Worth It? A New Study Says No

Many believe fish oil and vitamin D pills can reduce risk for cancer and heart disease, but the results of a new clinical trial suggests it’s a waste of money.

Spend that money on fruits and vegetables instead.

By Melissa Matthews, Men’s Health
  • A large, government-funded study concluded that vitamin D and omega-3 fatty acids do not prevent cancer or heart-related conditions.
  • One expert says there's no reason to take vitamin D supplements.
  • Future studies are needed to determine whether these supplements can help with other health conditions.
People commonly take supplements to slow aging and ward off illness, but if you're banking on vitamin D or omega-3 fatty acids to prevent a stroke or cancer, it's time to save your money. Now, the largest clinical trial conducted on these supplements concluded that neither are effective in stopping cancer or heart-related conditions.

For years, research indicated that people with low levels of vitamin D or those who eat less fish may be at greater risk for developing heart problems or cancer. But these studies were mostly observational, meaning researchers simply spotted patterns in a sample of people. This new data comes from a controlled clinical trial where nearly 26,000 people received either the supplements or a placebo. Published in The New England Journal of Medicine, the paper concluded that omega-3 fatty acids and vitamin D weren't any better than placebos in preventing cancer or cardiovascular conditions such as heart attacks, strokes or death from heart-related problems.

Although the study authors concluded that vitamin D and fish oil were useless in preventing cancer or overall cardiovascular disease, they did find that omega-3 fatty acids may lower risk of heart attack by 28 percent in healthy adults. And they saw that African-Americans who took daily omega-3 fatty acids reduced their risk of heart attack by 77 percent.

So with that positive news, why are the supplements still considered unhelpful? Dr. Clifford Rosen, M.D. of the Maine Medical Research Center explains to that you can't just slice that good news out of this data and act on it.

It comes down to "a whole different statical approach," Rosen explains. The study was designed to look at major cardiovascular events, which includes a variety of conditions like heart attack or stroke. But when you start pulling out separate cardiovascular conditions, like heart attacks only, an entirely different statistical analysis and testing needs to be done, he says.

"It should be tested in a larger formalized trial," he explains. "It may have some possibilities. I think the fish oil is still up in the air," Rosen says.

Not so for D. In an accompanying editorial, Rosen said he thinks the door is closed for that vitamin. In other words, it's not worth taking if you're worried about heart-related conditions and cancer, which is what this study investigated. But there's a chance it could be helpful for other diseases that haven't been studied so carefully yet.

What if you've had your D levels tested and they're low? You might need further testing more than you need a supplement. Rosen believes doctors should consider whether other health conditions, such as bowel or liver diseases, may be the root of low vitamin D levels.

Instead of either supplement, Rosen advises everyone to focus on the science-backed pillars of good health: exercise and eating plenty of fruits, vegetables, nuts, and yes, fish.
vitamin d, how to prevent heart disease, how to prevent cancer, cancer prevention, heart health


|Featured Content_$type=three$c=3$l=0$m=0$s=hide$rm=0

Made with in NYC

Acne,1,Advice,42,AIDS,1,Alcohol,5,Allergy,5,Alternative Treatments,1,Animal Health,1,Asthma,3,Autism,1,Back Pain,27,Birth Control,1,Cancer,74,Children's Health,19,Clinical Practice,1,Coronavirus,8,Dandruff,1,Dental Health,26,Dentistry,1,Depression,23,Diabetes,25,Diet,132,Disease,114,Drink,26,Drugs,3,Ears,3,Exercises,49,Eye Health,29,Fat Loss,76,Featured,91,Features,162,Fitness,620,Fitness & Exercise,218,Flue,1,Food,79,Fruits,4,General,7,Get Healthy,68,Halloween,2,Headache,23,heal,1,Health,283,Health & Fitness,300,Health Care,531,Health Insurance,1,Healthcare Tech,6,Healthy,12,Healthy Eating,190,Healthy Habits,197,Healthy Living,143,Hearing,6,HIV/AIDS,4,Legs,1,Life,1,LifeStyle,3,Massage,5,Meditation,30,Men & Women,18,Men's Health,12,Mental Health,315,Multiple Sclerosis,1,Muscle Gain,2,Nutrition,462,Oral,4,Pain,23,Pregnancy,71,Psychology,1,Recipes,52,Safety,5,Self-care,15,Sex,7,Sexual Health,19,Shaving,1,Skin Care,34,Sleep,64,Smile,1,Snacks,1,Special,6,Special Feature,111,Stress Relief,35,Stroke,2,Teeth,5,Therapy,3,Tips,108,True Health,5,Vegetables,3,Weight Gain,23,Weight Loss,506,Wellness,82,Women's Health,172,Workouts,84,Yoga,61,
Health Magazine: Are Vitamin D and Fish Oil Supplements Worth It? A New Study Says No
Are Vitamin D and Fish Oil Supplements Worth It? A New Study Says No
Many believe fish oil and vitamin D pills can reduce risk for cancer and heart disease, but the results of a new clinical trial suggests it’s a waste of money.
Health Magazine
Loaded All Posts Not found any posts VIEW ALL Read More Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS PREMIUM CONTENT IS LOCKED STEP 1: Share to a social network STEP 2: Click the link on your social network Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy Table of Content